Ten travellers decide that a storm must be someone’s fault. Their test gives them a terrible answer.
By Anny BilanciaUpdated 10 November 2026
AI-generated illustration
Ten farmers were crossing a field when a violent thunderstorm overtook them.
They hurried into a half-ruined temple. It offered a roof, but not much reassurance. Thunder shook the air. Lightning flashed around the building.
Someone decided there must be a reason the storm would not leave them alone. One of the ten, they thought, must have done something wrong.
They needed a way to identify him.
So they hung their straw hats outside the door. Whoever owned the hat the wind carried away would have to leave the shelter.
It was an extraordinary amount to trust to a hat.
Almost immediately, one blew loose.
The other nine pushed its owner out into the rain. They showed him no pity. The test had spoken, and they felt safer with him gone.
Then lightning struck the temple.
The nine inside were killed. The man they had driven away survived.
In the fable’s final reversal, he had been the one good man among them. His presence had protected the others until they decided to throw him out.
They had invented a test to prove that somebody deserved to be abandoned. The story leaves their confidence looking far more dangerous than the hat that escaped into the wind.
About this retelling: Retells “Who Was the Sinner?”. A dark fable with a fatal storm; no graphic detail. The supernatural judgement belongs to the fable and is not presented as an explanation of lightning. Based on chapter IV of The Chinese Fairy Book (1921), edited by Richard Wilhelm and translated by Frederick H. Martens. This is one recorded version, retold here in new wording.
Saved on this device, in this browser. Your list does not follow you to another device and will disappear if you clear this browser’s storage. sign in to keep an account reading list across devices.
Saved for later and your character notebook are separate, private account collections. Only explicit saves and their times are stored. Remove items in their own collection; Clear my list affects read marks only.
About your reading list and privacy
You choose what to save. Opening a story does not add it to your list. Tap the panda to mark a story, and tap it again to undo.
Without an account, your list stays in this browser. Someone using the same browser may see it. With an account, your marked stories and mark times are saved on our website, so you can find them on another device. We do not copy your browser list into your account when you sign in.
Other readers cannot see your account list. Authorised site administrators can access stored data. On your reading shelf, use Clear my list to remove your saved marks. This does not delete your account. On a shared device, sign out when you finish.
An account does not sign you up for newsletter emails.
We use essential storage for security and your choices. With your permission, Independent Analytics counts visits, pages, devices and approximate locations on this site. It uses no analytics cookies. You can read the magazine and use the reading shelf without accepting statistics. Change your choice at any time.
Functional
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
Optional, cookie-free audience statistics stored on this website. We do not link them to your account or reading shelf. Browser identifiers change daily.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.